Hotels in Fishers Island

Free cancellation options if plans change

Earn rewards on every night you stay

Save more with Member Prices

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
Dec 8 - Dec 9
Tomorrow
Dec 9 - Dec 10
This weekend
Dec 12 - Dec 14
Next weekend
Dec 19 - Dec 21

Where to stay in Fishers Island?

Suite, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking, Kitchenette (with Sofabed) | In-room safe, desk, laptop workspace, blackout drapes
Best Western Mystic Hotel
Best Western Mystic Hotel
2.5 star property
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (450)
The price is $91
$105 total
includes taxes & fees
Jan 4 - Jan 5, 2026
Best Western Mystic Hotel
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
See more propertiesforward arrow

Top landmarks in Fishers Island

South Beach

Whether you want to hunt for sand dollars or smell the fresh air, South Beach is a spot you might want to check out, located 5 mi (8 km) from central Fishers Island. Enjoy the sunset by the shore at Williams Beach, Napatree Point, and Dubois Beach.
See properties

Learn more about Fishers Island

The region around Fishers Island is home to attractions such as South Beach and Ocean Beach Park.

See all hotels in Fishers Island
Race Rock Lighthouse, near Fisher's Island, New York.

Check out reviews of Fishers Island hotels guests love

Hampton Inn Norwich

Hampton Inn Norwich

10/10 Excellent
"Room was very clean, staff was extremely nice. "
John 1-night trip
Posted 3 days ago
Hampton Inn Norwich

Frequently asked questions

What hotels do travelers recommend in Fishers Island?
Guests like Hilton Mystic, Best Western Mystic Hotel and Hyatt Place Mystic.
Can I book a refundable hotel in Fishers Island?
If you're looking for the flexibility to change your plans to Fishers Island, most properties offer refundable* rates you can book. You can find these properties by searching our site and using the "fully refundable" filter to narrow down the results.
What will the weather in Fishers Island be like during my trip?
July and August are typically the warmest months in Fishers Island when the average temp is 69°F. January and February are the coldest months when the average temperature is 36°F. October and December are the months with the most rain.
Why should I book my Fishers Island hotel through Hotels.com?
There are lots of reasons to book your Fishers Island trip with us: our free cancellations on selected hotels gives you flexibility, and with One Key™, our rewards program, you will be able to earn and use OneKeyCash™* on all eligible bookings such as hotels, car rentals, flights, vacation rentals and more on Hotels.com, Expedia and Vrbo.

Keep exploring